For field work, I'd have a Lab. Hands down. I mean, for lower level, dabbling, any retriever would be fine for me because it's just something I do because the dog loves it. I don't think Goldens are generally hard headed (Golden people say that about Labs, BTW). Also, like the Labs, there are variations between different lines. I think Goldens tend to worry and become concerned with right vs. wrong and what they are supposed to do, and can get stressed out and sort of lose their brains or even shut down. They aren't as independent as Labs. Think about seeing eye dogs. Goldens are more likely to walk beside you and do what you want to do vs. walking ahead of you and making decisions. That said, there are a lot of talented field Goldens out there. Personally, I haven't seen many in my part of the world, but in looking at breeders and litters throughout the US, I'm seeing some really nice dogs at the MH and FT level who can also play in the conformation, obedience and agility rings. I really like both breeds and if I ever did get a Golden, I'd have a Lab, too.