Hello and welcome! When Fred bear was smaller (10 months) he loved his Nylabone Wubby* and of course the Avery's bumpers to retrieve. I learned early from my experience not to give him toys that looked like shoes, socks, boots Or hats.. Tennis balls were one of his favorite then a cheap football with a little air out.. He would t go on a walk without carrying that old nasty flat football the whole time. Not a lot of knowledge from me but I hope it helps! Good luck with your puppy!
** and the thick rope toy tied on both ends ohh boy that was a must have at bedtime! And too many toys at first got him really bored of all of them. But one or two then he picked out which one was his favorite (football)