My cats seem to be really picky (normal for a cat, right?). I've tried just about every premium food out there. Their initial reaction is "yay, something new! I like it" to be met with "ew, this again?" the next time I serve it. (FWIW, they hated TOTW--probably because it's a pate.)
Basically I've deduced they do not like any pate type food.
Granted it has a huge ingredient list, but my cats really like Fussie Cat canned. No pate, lots of bits of fish. They waste very little of several varieties.
That said, I once tried Primal freeze dried for them (at the time I had two cats). They both ate it up but one of them proceeded to puke half a dozen times afterward. I don't know if it was because it was raw or too rich or just what (but the same cat experienced the pukes after eating a lizard he had killed, so perhaps it's a raw problem?). I have also tried the frozen little nuggets, mixed in with the Fussie Cat and they're all okay with that. I wouldn't mind doing all Primal (that's what brand the dogs eat) but I don't want to do frozen as I can't get it from Chewy.