On my monitor your third counter top choice has a definite blue tinge. I think either of the first two counter tops choices would go very nicely with the sage paint on the cupboards. And with cherry. Personally I prefer light colours in a room I will be working in. I find my rooms that get lots of light get too much in either the morning or afternoon. Either I close blinds to keep heat out, so I'm in the dark. Or I close them to keep glare off, and I'm in the dark.
What fun. I was in a recently redone kitchen, quite modern and the bottom cupboards were a sleek dark, brownish grey while the top ones were the same finish but a very light, brownish grey. It might sound dull but it looked really nice, the two different cupboard colours.